Female:

• Danneel Harris → Michael Hartley.
• Emmy Rossum
• Felicity Jones ✓ → Michael Hartley.
• Jessica De Gouw ✓ → Damien Hallowstark.
• Priyanka Chopra

Male:

• Ben Barnes → Ian Cooper.
• Jack Falahee ✓ → Philip A. J. Crawley.
• Jared Padalecki ✓ → Gideon Cartwright.
• Jared Padalecki → Michael Hartley.
• Matthew Daddario → Ian Cooper.
• Misha Collins ✓ → Gideon Cartwright.

This or that:

• Alexandra Park / Tom Austen