Not necessarily my all time favorites, but songs I reeeeeally loved when I loved them.

• Life in a Northern Town Dream Academy (54)
• Wagon Wheel Old Crow Medicine Show (46)
• Brand New Day Joshua Radin (36)
• The Cave Mumford & Sons (30)
• Second Hand News Fleetwood Mac (29)
• Sweet and Low Augustana (26)
• Desperation Miranda Lambert (26)
• The Call Regina Spektor (24)
• Solsbury Hill Peter Gabriel (22)
• 10 Days Late Third Eye Blind (22)
• 10,000 Nights Alphabeat (21)
• Airplanes B.o.B. feat. Hayley Williams (21)
• Mountain Men Crash Kings (21)
• Good Arms vs Bad Arms Frightened Rabbit (21)
• Mama Who Bore Me Spring Awakening (21)
• Don't Forget Me When I'm Gone Glass Tiger (21)
• Erection The Faint (19)
• Liberation Day Ferras (19)
• Doctor My Eyes Jackson Browne (19)
• Anytime Eve 6 (18)
• The Modern Leper Frightened Rabbit (18)
• Girl Like That Matchbox 20 (18)
• Doubting Thomas Nickel Creek (18)
• Send Me On My Way Rusted Root (18)

Parenthesized # = Play Count