back when i was like 12 i was rly into creepypasta and had my own oc and believed in slendermansion and all that.. yikes. embarrassing here were my favs from back then tho

• ticci toby
• masky ( not even a pasta, hes from marblehornets)
• hoodie ( also from marblehornets )
• slenderman
• sally
• jeff the killer
• ben drowned
• eyeless jack
• laughing jack
• lost silver

none of these r creepy.. nor will they ever be.. but they give me cringe chills now which is its own type of fear o_o watch marblehornets, tribetwelve, and everymanhybrid. you wont regret it!!