My Top 10:

• The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
• In Bruges
• The Wrestler
• Wall-E
• Pineapple Express
• The Dark Knight
• The Fall
• Son of Rambow
• Milk
• Slumdog Millionaire

Honorable Mentions:

• Iron Man
• Man On Wire
• Let The Right One In
• Vicky Christina Barcelona
• Timecrimes
• Forgetting Sarah Marshall
• Burn After Reading
• Quantum of Solace
• Australia
• Tropic Thunder
• Be Kind Rewind
• JCVD

Bigggest Disappointments:

• Happy-Go-Lucky
• Revolutionary Road
• My Winnipeg
• Towelhead
• Jellyfish
• Australia
• Let The Right One In

Pleasant Surprises (that aren't great):

• Taken
• Cloverfield
• The Grand
• Step Brothers

Biggest Piles of Poop:

• Indiana Jones 4
• Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist
• Horton Hears A Who
• Semi-Pro
• Happy-Go-Lucky

[there are still some movies I want to see, so this probably isn't final]

(edited 07/28/11. I moved In Bruges and Pineapple Express up, Slumdog Millionaire down.)