I made this list when I still thought I was straight :D

• Will Turner (Pirates of the Caribbean)
• Mamoru Chiba (Sailor Moon)
• Derek Sheperd (Grey's Anatomy)
• Eric (The Little Mermaid)
• Aragorn (Lord of the Rings)
• Mr. Bingley (Pride & Prejudice)
• Graham (The Holiday)
• Anthony Hope (Sweeney Todd)
• Robert (Enchanted)
• Galileo Figaro (We Will rock you Musical)
• The Death (Elisabeth Musical)
• Samwise Gamgee (Lord of the Rings)
• Seiya (Sailor Moon)
• Graham/Huntsman (Once upon a time)
• Jace Lightwood (The Mortal Instruments)
• Peeta "Bread" Mellark (The Hunger Games Trilogy)
• Nikolai Lantsov (Grisha Trilogy)