- Ken Amada:
- "okay isa's ken is off the chains and here's why[:] he manages to pull off that slightly-grieving and ominous edge that he has in p3's original writing. it's like you can tell how hyper serious he can be even when he's saying lighthearted things"
- "you bust out this like flawless ken and im jsut 0: [...] like you clearly have to extrapolate a lot for ken but he feels so natural"
- "i think your ken is like. the best possible ken we could have tbh [...] he's polite and formal but protective of the people he cares about"
- Sebastian Debeste: "i think sebastian can be a character who is so difficult to get a handle on and he felt really really good here!! he can be inquisitive and dense and tenacious and self-conscious and proud and it all fit in here!"
- Sonic the Hedgehog:
- "We love to see some homies who know sonic FRFR"
- "isa gets sonic really well from what i know [...] like, really well"
- Amy Rose: "I love this Amy, the openly in love Amy who is not afraid and is not ashamed to say and show how she feels, I think it takes a lot of courage to behave that way. And her devotion and her love for Sonic seems super cute to me hehehe"
- Miu Iruma: "It's really intriguing to watch you fix all that Canon had made nasty with a personal touch of Isa magic without at all getting rid of the traits she exhibits as a whole. Getting to interact with your Iruma is truly a gift."
- Nene Hayashida: [insert long rambling paragraphs from multiple people dedicated to analyzing this guy's motivations and development]
- Jun Kurosu: "Holy [...] I forgot this group did this kind of thing commonly. But also good shit. But also holy fuck."
- Clive: "Clive is literally my little meow meow— speaking of, i ADORE how you wrote him in the fic. i feel like some people forget that Clive is literally this manipulative person… so when it’s actually explored I think it’s really interesting ^^"
- Yoon: "You write Yoon's thoughts with such a thoughtful and practiced approach that it feels as though I'm really reading him as he is from the manga."
- Ashley and Andrew Graves:
- "i love your characterization of the two btw its so friggin spot on [...] ive never seen someone so accurately capture the gears turning in ashleys head."
- "You capture their hopelessly toxic dynamic flawlessly, and the premise is so interesting it literally had me scouring this plot versus the game itself, trying to compare and contrast all the juicy details you hint at."
- "I’m a sucker for fanfics that aren’t just mindless smut and really dive deep into Andrew and Ashley’s characters. And by god you nail them to a capital T!"
- "The characterization in this is so on point. Literally everyone in here hasn't done or said anything that seems out of character. I can't get this story out of my head as much as the game 😭 IT'S SO GOOD AAAAAAAAAAAAA. "
- "I’ve been reading since chapter 1 and I can say this is by far the best TCOAAL fanfiction I’ve read. You’ve really nailed the characters here and it genuinely reads like the in game story. The inclusion of the traumatic events of the siblings childhoods totally strengthens their characters and makes them feel very authentic and I love the focus on the character dynamics and relationships, by far the best aspect of the game. Keep up the excellent work. :)"
may 31 2023 ∞
apr 8 2025 +