minimal (for me)

• pizza-desu; a bit vertical: http://pizza-desu.tumblr.com/tagged/pizzathm
• beenzin-o; a bit fandom, hover permalinks: http://dok2.co.vu/tagged/themes
• bribery; simple, mix: http://bribery.tumblr.com/tagged/theme (old themes = http://pastebin.com/u/seouless)
• sekae; kind of fandom but nice \o/: http://sehvn.co.vu/tagged/theme
• shoseii; could also work for anime, colorful: http://shoseii.tumblr.com/thm
• mil

simple (not for me)

• yobeo; mixed 1-2 column, topbar/sidebar: http://yobeo.tumblr.com/tagged/themes
• radiotomics; mixed 1-2 column, top/sidebar: http://radiotomics.tumblr.com/
• zious; simple 1 column sidebar: http://zious.tumblr.com/tagged/theme
• nunmuri; sidebar w/ large posts gen: http://nunmurithemes.tumblr.com/themesnunmuri

vintage

• slanting; typical vintage 1/2 columns : http://gentlethemes.tumblr.com/

fandom

• etrothemes; large posts, sidebars: http://etrothemes.tumblr.com/tagged/theme
• str-wrs; some fandom vertical + vintage mixed: http://str-wrs.tumblr.com/all