co-written with samira xD an 'x' denotes disagreement, followed by an 's' if sam likes him or a 'c' if caitlin does

the bad boy

• judd nelson (80's)
• ian somerhalder

the musician - the rocker

• josh ramsay
• tyson ritter
• blink 182 xs
• adam lambert xc

the musician - the acoustic cutie

• luke walton

indie interests

• the maine
• all time low
• dave monks (tokyo police club) xs
• forever the sickest kids xs
• owl city
• boys like girls
• relient k xs
• stereos xc
• shaant hacikyan (curse of curves days)
• metro station
• the latency
• brendon urie (i write sins not tragedies days)

the pretty boy

• andrew mccarthy (80's) xs
• usher
• varsity fanclub
• zac efron
• adam levine

the attractive jerk

• jude law

the funny guy

• shia labeouf
• penn badgley

fuck me now

• taylor lautner
• chace crawford
• tom kaulitz xc
• bill kaulitz xc

the jock

• david beckham
• channing tatum

the adorable nerd

• adam brody
• joseph gordon-levitt
• alex day xc

the cutie

• jackson rathbone
• ed speleers (eragon)
• aaron johnson (angus thongs) xs
• jonathan jackson
• mark ruffalo

the exotic foreigner

• johnathan rhys meyers
• ewan mcgregor

the beautiful brit

• ed westwick
• ben barnes
• william moseley
• tom felton
• robert pattinson xc

the dilf/male cougar -rawwrrr!-

• johnny depp (as a pirate)
• george clooney
• hugh jackman
• rob lowe
• harrison ford
• will smith

the homespun hottie

• ryan gosling
• ryan reynolds

possible other categories

• strong, silent type
• the charmer

soon to come, a female version of this list ;)