⭐ - liked, ✨ - wasn't necessarily good or very scary but i liked one (or more) of the characters

• ao oni
• at dead of night
• baldi's basics
• beary the hatchet ⭐
• beware the shadowcatcher
• buckshot roulette
• classmates ✨
• cooking companions
• crooked man
• dead plate ⭐
• doxxed ⭐
• dreaming mary ⭐
• file.exe
• fran bow
• gavril ✨
• go! go! hamster chef! ⭐
• gornom
• happy birthday balvenie ⭐
• helltown ⭐
• house hunted ✨
• ib
• idolize
• imscared
• in silence
• kindergarten
• kuro oni
• liar liar ✨
• mausoleosis ✨
• misao
• missing
• mistrick ⭐
• monster parlor
• mycopsychosis ⭐
• needy streamer overload
• out of hands ⭐
• rental
• sacritice ⭐
• sally face ⭐✨
• shut in
• simulacra
• someone stole my lunch! ✨
• spooky's jumpscare mansion
• tentador leches ✨
• the bunny graveyard
• the coffin of andy and leyley
• the convenience store
• the house
• the man from the window
• the man from the window 2
• the mortuary assistant
• the vermander curse
• the witch's house
• today i'm harvesting you ✨
• trapped with jester ✨
• who wants to be a murderer?