The rules of this game are way too confusing so I mean just go with it

Jess

• Seaway (can't be stolen)
• Neck Deep
• letlive
• Northlane
• ✔ Set it Off
• ✔ Roam
• Motion City Soundtrack
• Julevera
• The Used
• As It Is
• ✔ STOLEN#1 - Knuckle Puck
• ✔ STOLEN#2 - Real Friends
• ✔ STOLEN#3 - Sleeping with Siren

Nate

• ✔ State Champs (can't be stolen)
• ✔ Four Year Strong
• Modern Baseball
• Knuckle Puck
• Real Friends
• Have Mercy
• Reliant K
• Sleeping with Sirens
• Hawthorne Heights
• Brigades
• ✔ NEW ADDITION#1 - Vanna
• ✔ NEW ADDITION#2 - New Found Glory
• NEW ADDITION #3 - A Day to Remember

Jess: 5, Nate: 4. I WIN