• Data is from September 12th, 2025
• Most popular - Shadows on Society Hill: An Addy Mystery (4.16)
• Least popular - Lost in the City: A Julie Mystery (3.71)

In time era order -

• The Silent Stranger: A Kaya Mystery (3.98)
• The Ghost Wind Stallion: A Kaya Mystery (3.98)
• Peril at King's Creek: A Felicity Mystery (4.09)
• Traitor in Williamsburg: A Felicity Mystery (4.07)
• Lady Margaret's Ghost: A Felicity Mystery (3.97)
• Traitor in the Shipyard: A Caroline Mystery (4.11)
• The Traveler's Tricks: A Caroline Mystery (3.98)
• The Smuggler's Secrets: A Caroline Mystery (4.13)
• Secrets in the Hills: A Josefina Mystery (4.01)
• The Glowing Heart: A Josefina Mystery (3.90)
• The Hidden Gold: A Marie-Grace Mystery (3.91)
• The Haunted Opera: A Marie-Grace Mystery (3.96)
• The Cameo Necklace: A Cecile Mystery (4.05)
• The Runaway Friend: A Kirsten Mystery (3.95)
• Shadows on Society Hill: An Addy Mystery (4.16)
• The Curse of Ravenscourt: A Samantha Mystery (4.08)
• The Stolen Sapphire: A Samantha Mystery (4.07)
• The Cry of the Loon: A Samantha Mystery (4.06)
• Clue in the Castle Tower: A Samantha Mystery (3.99)
• Danger in Paris: A Samantha Mystery (4.14)
• Secrets at Camp Nokomis: A Rebecca Mystery (3.92)
• A Bundle of Trouble: A Rebecca Mystery (3.94)
• The Crystal Ball: A Rebecca Mystery (3.92)
• A Growing Suspicion: A Rebecca Mystery (3.79)
• The Showstopper: A Rebecca Mystery (3.84)
• Danger at the Zoo: A Kit Mystery (4.06)
• Midnight in Lonesome Hollow: A Kit Mystery (3.98)
• Missing Grace: A Kit Mystery (4.00)
• A Thief in the Theater: A Kit Mystery (4.06)
• Intruders at Rivermead Manor: A Kit Mystery (4.02)
• The Jazzman's Trumpet: A Kit Mystery (3.97)
• Menace at Mammoth Cave: a Kit Mystery (3.83)
• The Legend of the Shark Goddess: A Nanea Mystery (3.79)
• A Spy on the Home Front: A Molly Mystery (4.07)
• The Light in the Cellar: A Molly Mystery (4.09)
• Clues in the Shadows: A Molly Mystery (4.10)
• The Finders Keepers Rule: A Maryellen Mystery (3.84)
• The Runaway: A Maryellen Mystery (3.84)
• The Lady's Slipper: A Melody Mystery (3.77)
• The Tangled Web: A Julie Mystery (3.97)
• The Puzzle of the Paper Daughter: A Julie Mystery (4.14)
• The Silver Guitar: A Julie Mystery (3.79)
• Lost in the City: A Julie Mystery (3.71)
• Message in a Bottle: A Julie Mystery (4.01)

Interesting trivia -

• Cecile, Kirsten, Addy, Nanea, and Melody only have one mystery book (and only one is not a POC)
• Felicity, Marie-Grace, and Molly have more than one book but none that were rebranded as a Beforever version
• Kit has the most mysteries with 7 books
• Kaya and Maryellen have the same score for both of their mysteries
• Rebecca's mysteries do not reach a score at or above 4.0
• Molly's mysteries do not have a book that scored below a 4.0