Ending IX: The Heart of the Shop - I feel its rhythmic pulse. I am enveloped in its warm embrace.
Ending II: Disturbed Sleep - I'm tormented by memories of Barton Potter's death, but Undermare is safe once more.
- Barton Potter: Deceased, killed by some eldritch entity while trying to give the casket to the nameless god.
- Bonnie Robertson: Insane, her thoughts are scattered after being sliced with the Diverging Hook.
- Audrey Bell: Deceased, murdered by her own bloodthirsty followers when they saw her weakness.
Ending VII: A Noble Death - The casket has been destroyed, but at what cost?
- Eli White: Deceased, he sacrificed himself to save us.
- Verona Green: Deceased, killed by your own hand.
- Bonnie Robertson: Insane, her thoughts are scattered after being sliced with the Diverging Hook.
- Audrey Bell: Deceased, murdered by her own bloodthirsty followers when they saw her weakness.
Ending VIII: A Seductive Power - The power of the casket could not be contained. I fear nothing. I feel nothing.
- Eli White: Cursed, when the casket was opened.
- Verona Green: Cursed, she remains under the spell of the casket.
- Rebecca Rose: Cursed, when the casket was opened.
- Barton Potter: Cursed, when the casket was opened.
- Jack Hungerford: Cursed, he remains in the trance of the casket. At least he was spared death.
- Bonnie Robertson: Insane, her thoughts are scattered after being sliced with the Diverging Hook.
- Audrey Bell: Deceased, murdered by her own bloodthirsty followers when they saw her weakness.
Ending V: In the Lap of the Gods - The nameless gods have the casket. Our fate is in their hands.
- Bonnie Robertson: Missing, she fled after trying and failing to murder Barton Potter and has not been seen since.
- Audrey Bell: Deceased, murdered by her own bloodthirsty followers when the casket was not opened.
- Jack Hungerford: Insane, he never recovered after falling deeper into the trance. His mind is forever broken.
Ending I: Catastrophe Avoided - The casket has been destroyed, and Undermere is safe again.
- Bonnie Robertson: Missing, she fled after trying and failing to murder Barton Potter and has not been seen since.
- Audrey Bell: Deceased, murdered by her own bloodthirsty followers when the casket was not opened.
- Jack Hungerford: Insane, he never recovered after falling deeper into the trance. His mind is forever broken.
Ending III: Divine Retribution - A fatal error has been made. Death and darkness cover the land.
- Eli White: Cursed, when the casket was opened.
- Verona Green: Cursed, when the casket was opened.
- Rebecca Rose: Missing, it is not known what happened to her after the casket was opened.
- Bonnie Robertson: Missing, she fled after trying and failing to murder Barton Potter and has not been seen since.
- Jack Hungerford: Insane, he never recovered after falling deeper into the trance. His mind is forever broken.
Ending IV: Holgar's Wrath - I put my trust in a serpent-tongued Priest and a vengeful god. I must reap the consequences.
- Eli White: Cursed, when the casket was opened.
- Verona Green: Cursed, when the casket was opened.
- Rebecca Rose: Missing, it is not known what happened to her after the casket was opened.
- Bonnie Robertson: Missing, she fled after trying and failing to murder Barton Potter and has not been seen since.
- Audrey Bell: Deceased, killed by your own hand during the sacrament ceremony.
- Jack Hungerford: Insane, he never recovered after falling deeper into the trance. His mind is forever broken.
Ending VI: A Lucky Escape - Undermere was saved, but at the loss of a dear friend. I cannot stay here now.
- Verona Green: Deceased, she gave her life to save us all.
- Bonnie Robertson: Missing, she fled after trying and failing to murder Barton Potter and has not been seen since.
- Audrey Bell: Deceased, murdered by her own bloodthirsty followers when the casket was not opened.
- Jack Hungerford: Insane, he never recovered after falling deeper into the trance. His mind is forever broken.