When I checked out this book, the librarian said, "This is a hard read." She was correct, but not in the way she intended. This book made it hard for me not to do the following:
- beat the book with a baseball bat
- beat up the characters
- burn the book
- kill myself
- punch the book
- rip my hair out
- rip the book apart
- run the book through the shredder
- scream
- scribble on the pages
- stab the book
- stomp on the book
- tear out the pages
- throw the book
Just a few reasons that reading this book was literal torture:
- CHARACTER-CENTRIC
- not a single likable character
- they're written horrendously
- I want to pop all their heads off like a dandelion
- everyone constantly switches between "woe is me" and "look at me, I'm such a hero"
- everyone is so annoying oh my God
- forced diversity (note: author is a member of We Need Diverse Books and founder of DiversifYA)
- Autumn and Sylvia’s characters focus entirely on each other
- Sylvia and Tomás think Spanish randomly, call their mom Mamá and their grandpa Abuelo, and mention they mention a Spanish lullaby; all we know is they are from a Spanish-speaking family
- every time Fareed is mentioned, so is his accent; he is such a flat character, and his race is his main trait
- random diverse characters just for the sake of diversity
- there’s no way Alabama is this diverse
- absolutely horrendous relationship between Autumn and Sylvia
- Autumn feels that Sylvia doesn't understand her love for dance
- when Autumn meets Aisha they have better chemistry because they both are passionate about dance
- no chemistry
- their characters center each other
- can’t trust one another
- they barely talk
- Chapter Fourteen: Autumn
- she starts dancing to save everyone???????
- "'...You never cared abut any of us. You only ever cared about dance.'"
- "'So dance. You wanted a stage. Take it'" (161)
- "And then I see her face. Sylv's the only person who matters. Our late summer nights are the only time I've been happy" (163)
- literally proving Tyler's point that all she cares about is Sylvia (brought up at a different point in the book) and dance
- thinking about it gives me a headache
- the multiple times Autumn is almost shot but isn't (I wish she died)
- the author couldn't bear to kill off one of the main-main characters
- Sylvia in general (worst character)
- Chapter Fifteen: Tomás
- he asks out a girl whilst trying to get people out of the auditorium and gets mad when she doesn't say anything???
- "'Hey, want to go out? The doors are open'" (172)
- when I read this I was shocked, flabbergasted, astounded, dumbfounded... I couldn't believe it was real
- "I didn't expect for her to fall for me like a knight in shining armor, but I would have liked a smile or some indication that I'm helping to save her." (172)
- a few seconds later, she says thank you
- "I don't move from my crouch. My heart hammers, and it isn't from fear or dread." (173)
- weird and out-of-place romantic scenes between Claire and Chris
- " Chris's fingers brush mine. 'I never thought you needed to win to be perfect.'" (86)
- they are running to get help
- Claire and Chris forcing the police to let them help
- ALSO, CLARIE INITIALLY HOLDS BACK IMPORTANT INFORMATION FROM THE COPS?? AND THEN SHE GETS TO HELP???
- Chapter Twenty-Two: Claire
- their stupid, out-of-place romance even appears whilst sticking their big fat noses in police business
- "Strong arms wrap themselves around me as Chris pulls me into a hug. His heartbeat thumps against my cheek. I place my hand on the nape of his neck, tracing his goose bumps. His hand trails form my shoulders to my ears as he pushes a strand of hair out of the way.
- "'You are so brave,' Chris's voice rumbles, deep and low." (247)
- there's no way this would ever happen
- Claire is literally useless
- she didn't help or advance the story at all, her point of view should have been replaced by her brother, Matt’s, or Tyler’s (I think this was the best option)
- the "good" Tyler that everyone loves and misses so much was a terrible person
- OTHER
- blatant ripoff of Nineteen Minutes by Jodi Picoult
- boring
- anticlimactic
- unrealistic and nonsensical
- "Opportunity High"
- "('no pun intended')" (2)
- reference to title
- "Together, we'll get out. Together, we'll survive this. Together, we'll be strong enough to face whatever comes our way.
- "This is where it ends." (205)
- writing style
- This. Thing. Especially.
- the book is essentially a (very VERY bad) fanfiction
- insanely slow paced
- "time slows when in danger": cool concept, executed poorly
- WAY too long
- there’s no good place to stop reading
- switching perspectives
- sometimes I like it, but I don’t like how it was done in this book
- every single perspective change ends... weird?
- it reads like it should be the end of the chapter or book if that makes any sense
- flashbacks
- I groaned and rolled my eyes every time I was forced to endure one
- tweets and blogs
- "@CADETCJJ Can we ask you some questions about the situation at #OHS? Our reporters would like to get in touch." (106)
- large number of characters can be a little confusing
- the name "Nyah"
The things I didn’t hate:
- it made me feel an emotion other than anger twice
- Chapter Seventeen: Autumn and Chapter Nineteen: Autumn
- Chapter Twenty-Four: Sylv
- the hate (I do not use this term lightly) this book brewed inside of me caused me to finish it in two days
- 74 pages on day 1 and the remaining 208 the next day
ranking: This Is Where It Ends narrators
I seriously do not understand why this book is praised so much.