- 1998: in the aeroplane over the sea, neutral milk hotel
- 1999: when the pawn..., fiona apple
- 2000: stories from the city, stories from the sea, pj harvey
- 2001: amnesiac, radiohead
- 2002: i brought you my bullets, you brought me your love, my chemical romance
- 2003: absolution, muse
- 2004: three cheers for sweet revenge, my chemical romance
- 2005: illinois, sufjan stevens
- 2006: the black parade, my chemical romance
- 2007: in rainbows, radiohead
- 2008: fearless, taylor swift
- 2009: brand new eyes, paramore
- 2010: speak now, taylor swift
- 2011: suck it and see, arctic monkeys
- 2012: the idler wheel..., fiona apple
- 2013: trouble will find me, the national
- 2014: 1989, taylor swift
- 2015: depression cherry, beach house
- 2016: puberty 2, mitski
- 2017: melodrama, lorde
- 2018: boygenius, boygenius
- 2019: norman fucking rockwell!, lana del rey
- 2020: folklore, taylor swift
- 2021: sour, olivia rodrigo
- 2022: dance fever, florence + the machine
- 2023: this is why, paramore
nov 1 2018 ∞
jan 12 2024 +